A “Crisis” since 1979, and still no approved solution
A "Crisis" since 1979
And still no approved solution
Photo used with permission, courtesy: FixPointLobosDangers.org
Four miles from my house is Point Lobos State Natural Reserve, often called the "crown jewel" of California State Parks. Unfortunately, it's gone from a gem overlooked, to a gem trampled over.
But the most urgent problem isn't even on the property. It's the chaos of getting visitors into it – without getting killed on their way.
Imagine walking for a mile along a tightrope of space between parked and high-speed cars, other pedestrians, bikes and motorcycles – all trying to get by on mere inches of asphalt along historic two-lane Highway 1. Carrying your jacket, water bottle, maybe holding hands with a toddler or a great-grandmother, the trek could easily be your last as cars whiz by at top speed.
A headline on a local site gets to the heart of the issue: “Must someone die before officials act?”
It's an insanely unsafe choreography, played out not just on holidays or weekends but every day, all year long. And it seems the more people do it – the more people do it. As if the social proof that others are doing it makes it safer than it (obviously) is not.
Since 1979, "alarms have been raised"...
In 1979, there was an outcry by locals and officials to address the growing tide of 100,000 visitors a year. Today, the volume of visitors is tenfold that. Thanks in part to Instagram and TikTok, 1 million of us will stampede through the nature preserve, exponentially impacting a legacy of problems:
- Heavy traffic, dangerous driving behavior, and illegal parking
- Impediments for emergency service responses
- Limited access to public lands
- Lack of staff for enforcement
- Trespassing
- Ecological degradation
And yet – no plans or solutions have been adopted to address these problems.
That is, until now. Maybe. If it doesn’t stall, yet again.
For nearly 10 years, a community-based initiative to create a parking lot, shuttle service and reservation system to remedy the currently legal, but hazardous, parking along the highway has stalled.
What's taken so long?
Perhaps even more complex than getting into Point Lobos is that several agencies are responsible for managing the area:
- California State Parks
- CALTRANS
- Monterey County Supervisors & Planning Commission
- California Coastal Commission
- CalFire
- California Highway Patrol
- Monterey County Sheriff’s Office
No single entity gets total control over the implementation of a solution, but each has veto power in the process. (Hence, easy decision-making gridlock, especially as constituents put pressure on elected officials within each of these agencies to “be responsive”.)
The (real) cause for the decade of delay is less obvious.
Even the dynamic of several agencies getting a say isn't enough to stall a plan for half a century. And almost never is the delay a lack of engineering know-how...
(That's definitely not the cause in this case -- as one County Commissioner boiled the solution down to: "[We're simply voting on] a permeable parking lot, ticket machine, couple of bathrooms, and a fence [with some] people to shuttle people to and from the Reserve.")
In other words, the decades of delay isn't a result of an inability to technically solve the problems at hand.
Nor is it a lack of willingness among the professionals within these government entities to collaborate.
So why hasn’t anything been done to address these issues for nearly 50 years?
As is almost always the case, the hold-up is the impacts people fear, both real and perceived.
More importantly, some of the issues raised by opponents seem to be surrogates for the real source of opposition.
Last month, the County Planning Commission made a clear and unanimous vote to keep the plan alive by allowing it to be put out to bid, before returning for final approval. What’s less clear is how previous efforts by opponents to obstruct the plan have been addressed to prevent them from doing so yet again.
Some of the pushback is over direct impacts, such as:
- increased risk of flooding to neighboring homes
- incentive for trespassers to circumvent the reservation system
- limiting access based on affordability
- increased traffic at surrounding intersections and developments
- aesthetic changes to area adjacent to the parking lot.
But those aren't the Key Issues...
The issues that caught my attention were hardly on the radar, from what I could tell. In part because they weren’t well articulated, and were not from the typical “stakeholder” (one was from a fellow policymaker and the other from a former County employee, and some that have yet to be voiced):
- A spokesperson for the Coastal Commission, one of the agencies that will have to give final approval to the plan, vaguely stated the plan would fail to address “holistic concerns,” but he didn’t expand on his (or the Commission’s possible) rejection of the plan.
- A planner and former employee called in and stated that if the plan is pursued without his concerns for prescriptive rights being fully addressed, he'll fight it with legal action.
And one I find troubling that was never directly raised is that:
- When locals (who aren’t tuned-in to the details of the plan) realize they’ll need to make reservations months in advance to visit a local site for a day-hike, many will suddenly become engaged – if not also enraged...
There’s no clear timeline on when the plan will be back for another vote, so we'll see how this case unfolds.
In the meantime, the innumerable problems persist, including people’s lives are at risk, and the sentiments of sleeping "Silent Majority” are yet to be fully known.
While we wait and watch what happens with this plan -- I'm curious, what situations are happening in your backyard?
Let me know and we'll take a look at the issues and interests through the lens of Consent-Building for you.
Other Will This Project Survive? Posts